Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026

Synodality and the Church

Dr Pravin Thevasathan

Dr Pravin ThevathasanMany of us have long believed that the synodal process could be used in an attempt at changing the consistent and continuous teachings of the Catholic Church especially regarding sexual morality. Our worst suspicions appear to have now been confirmed: the Study Group 9 of the Synod on Synodality has been widely criticised for a blatant attempt at transforming the Church's teachings on homosexuality.

There are certain terms that we need to be suspicious of: "paradigm shift" and "emergent reality", for example. Students of the Modernist heresy can immediately recognise these terms for what they are: a noxious cocktail of Teilhardism and Rahner-lite. According to these theories, doctrine is not simply developing but is in a state of flux or becoming: we become who we are called to be. For one proponent of change, what is needed is "ecclesial and magisterial discernment" in the name of "pastorality." This "inductive method" looks at the Church's teachings on homosexuality and "uses it to construct a paradigm for how we can move from one set of attitudes to another." The consistent teachings of the Church is thus dismissed as an "attitude!"

The document produced by Study Group 9 chose to target the truly Catholic apostolate for people with same-sex attraction, Courage. Its members are said to be "lonely" and "depressed." Members I have spoken with said they were lonely and depressed while engaging in the homosexual lifestyle and have found freedom, peace, and joy only when following the teachings of the Church.

If synodality means anything at all, it must include listening to all people including those engaged in the Courage apostolate. Above all else, we need a teaching Church, not just one that listens.

Reference

  • Learning to be Catholic by James Alison, 16 May, 2026, The Tablet