Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026
In response to Drs Pullicino and Burke
Jon Rogers
Introduction
In their paper in the August edition of this journal[1] Drs Pullicino and Burke comment on recently updated guidance from the Catholic Bishops of New York State on end-of-life (EoL) decision-making[2]. Similar to an earlier paper by Fr Pullicino[3], to which I have also written a response, this latest offering is beset with flaws, misrepresentation and misunderstanding and is consequently misleading and risks causing harm.
The bishops address the challenges of EoL decision-making in the context of Church teaching in a clear, sensitive and informed manner, including the important and too-often neglected subject of advanced care planning. It is therefore unfortunate that Drs Pullicino and Burke choose to look backwards to the inadequacies the Liverpool Care Pathway (LCP) while being either unaware of or ignoring the positive developments since its demise. Consequently, their criticism is ill-informed and risks deterring people from reading and benefitting from the bishops’ wisdom and compassion.
While championing, quite rightly, the fundamental right to life they seem to extrapolate, giving the impression that they also advocate for a clinging-on to life, an expectation not mandated in Church teaching. It is worth noting that Evangelium Vitae[4] recognises that death can be “clearly imminent and inevitable” (para 65) and, in the context of analgesia and/or sedation to palliate symptoms, while some may decline these in order “to share consciously in the Lord's Passion”, doing so is not a duty (para 64).
In this response I will consider some of the flaws in their commentary and then focus on the issue of medically assisted hydration and nutrition, a topic that seems to cause them particular concern.
Flaws
- They are either unaware of, or choose not to refer to, positive developments in palliative and EoL care since the demise of the LCP. These developments include the approach to caring for dying people developed by the Leadership Alliance for the Care of Dying People[5], published the year after the review into the LCP; strategic planning for improving palliative and EoL care[6]; holistic and personalised care guided by the Gold Standards Framework (GSF)[7], which is demonstrably not a “pathway”; the clearly stated principles and standards of care detailed in NICE quality standards[8], GMC professional standards[9] and, finally, evidenced guidance from NICE[10] and, relating to prescribing, in the Palliative Care Formulary[11].
- The authors seem unaware that NICE guidance on shared decision-making[12] and best-interests decision-making[13] includes the importance of involving patient views (either directly, or pre-stated through advanced care planning) and those of family members, friends, carers or advocates. In trying to evidence their claim that best-interest decisions are a “legal fiction” they give undue weight to an 18-year-old opinion-piece[14] which does not deny the need to make such decisions but critiques the terminology (i.e. “best”) as attaining “unassailable objectivity” that might hinder necessary correction.
- They misrepresent the bishops’ guide[2], framing identification of the dying process as a “reason for withdrawal of fluids and nutrition”. This ignores the detail and nuance that the bishops bring to how this might be appropriate “under very specific circumstances”.
- The authors misrepresent the use of early warning scores such as NEWS2. These are not – as the authors seem to suggest – used in isolation when prognosticating imminent death. Further, the paper they reference[15] is a single centre retrospective study relating to death or ICU admission within 24 hours of admission to ED and thus not generalisable to the 57.2% off all deaths that occur outside of hospital settings[16].
- In a repeat of what Dr Pullicino did in his paper in the April edition of CMQ, and in an attempt to prove “self-fulfilling prophecy” when identifying when a patient might be entering the dying process, the authors inappropriately (at best tenuously) generalise from a 25-year-old retrospective study[17] of 87 patients relating to prognostication and support in a specific group of patients with catastrophic spontaneous intracerebral haemorrhage, treated in acute settings.
- While they are correct that diagnosis of imminent death can be challenging and reference a study of palliative care doctors’ prognostication via vignettes[18] to evidence this, they fail to acknowledge the study’s conclusions, i.e. that “clinical predictions will continue to have a role for routine prognostication” and that it is important to convey uncertainty in discussions with patients and their relatives. A more recent retrospective cohort study[19] utilised an Australia-modified Karnofsky Performance Status (AKPS) to predict death in comatose patients. The study identified a tipping point towards rapid decline 20-30 days before death, a 47% likelihood of death within 2 days and 84% likelihood within 4 days. The study acknowledged limitations, including scale and generalisability, but also warned that “a lack of awareness of approaching death” (i.e. failing to attempt and communicate prognostication in dying, despite the uncertainty) risks “negative bereavement outcomes”, i.e. avoidable harm.
- The authors question how nasogastric (NG) tubes might cause agitation, asking “how can you tell this unless the patient is awake?”[1]. NG tubes are not reserved for the unconscious.
Food and water
One of the indications that someone may be entering the dying process is an increasing lack of interest or willingness to eat and drink. This can be explained by the body having less nutritional demand as systems shut down. Drs Pullicino and Burke’s stance is problematic as it suggests a willingness to feed and hydrate someone against their will or their best interests.
The challenges of balancing benefits and harms in the face of a lack of high-quality evidence, including considering the beliefs, values and wishes of patients and their family/advocates, is pragmatically and sensitively covered in standards and guidelines. The risk of harms – e.g. fluid overload – cannot be overlooked. I refer readers to NICE NG31 recommendation 1.4[10], NICE quality statements QS144, statement 4[8] and GMC professional standards[9] (paras. 112-127).
I will give two examples from personal experience. I recognise these are anecdotes and not evidence, but they illustrate why I think that Drs Pullicino and Burke are wrong.
25 years ago, my mother had been fed for months via an NG tube, consequent to the chronic disease that was slowing killing her. One day, having returned to die at home after respite care in a hospice, she pulled her tube out. We questioned whether replacing the tube was of value, but she agreed to have it replaced on the advice of her consultant. What followed was an uncomfortable journey to A&E by ambulance, several hours waiting while doctors unfamiliar with her unusual case reviewed her extensive notes, NG replacement and the imaging required to confirm placement, then another uncomfortable ambulance journey home. She died the next day. Was that decision to have the tube replaced really in my mother’s best interests? In retrospect I think not: her penultimate day was more miserable than it needed to be.
More recently, I recognised the dying process in my father, as described in my response to Fr Pullicino’s previous paper[3]. Part of the evidence was a decreasing interest in food or fluids, until he was taking none. Providing oral care to moisten his mouth certainly was “ordinary means” but placing a NG tube - hardly a “natural means of preserving life”[1] - would certainly not have been. My father would not have wanted a NG tube: are Drs Pullicino and Burke suggesting that he should have been taken from his peaceful and attentive nursing home to have one inserted in order to be force-fed against his will, with all the distress it would cause? This would not have been compassion: it would have been cruelty.
Conclusion
The New York State bishops’ statement provides valuable and sensitive guidance to Catholics, whether patients or their relatives, friends or carers, relating to ethical and faithful decisions when approaching end of life. It wisely advocates for advanced care planning to help ensure that patients’ beliefs, values and wishes can be considered, even when they lack capacity.
I empathise if some past poor experience has prompted a seemingly entrenched – but erroneous – viewpoint in the authors. However, ignoring current best practice and evidence risks deterring people from good and ethical palliative and EoL care, just at the time where we need to be promoting its value to society in the face of the fears induced by the assisted death lobby and their claims to compassion. Organisations such as Dignity in Dying and My Death My Decision will willingly mislead people that a legalised state-sponsored assisted death system is a necessary protection from the distressing death that they are probably not going to experience. We need to be advocating for equitable provision of good quality palliative and end-of-life care, rather than denigrating it via misinformation.
As in my previous response, I have some requests of my CMA colleagues:
- If you have questions or concerns about end-of-life care, speak with an experienced colleague before coming to any conclusions.
- Read the New York State bishops guide.
- Recognise the importance of advanced care planning, as advocated in the guide, and do what you can to encourage and enable it among your patients and family.
Bibliography References
- Pullicino P, Burke WJ. Commentary on “A Catholic guide to end-of-life decision-making”. released by the Catholic Bishops Conference of New York State. April 20th, 2026. Catholic Medical Quarterly [Internet]. 2026 [cited 2026 Sept 1];76(3). Available from: https://www.cmq.org.uk/CMQ/2026/Aug/commentary_on_catholic_guide_to.html
- Catholic Bishops of New York State. Now and at the hour of our death: a Catholic guide to end-of-life decision-making [Internet]. 2026 [cited 2026 Sept 1] p. 1–12. Available from: https://www.nyscatholic.org/application/files/9817/7669/8773/Now_and_at_the_Hour_of_Our_Death.pdf
- Pullicino P. End of Life ‘Care’, euthanasia and assisted dying. Catholic Medical Quarterly. 2026;76(2):13–4.
- Pope John Paul II. Evangelium vitae [Internet]. www.vatican.va. 1995 [cited 2026 Sept 2]. Available from: https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_25031995_evangelium-vitae.html
- Leadership Alliance for the Care of Dying People. One chance to get it right: improving people’s experience of care in the last few days and hours of life [Internet]. 2014 June [cited 2026 Aug 27]. Available from: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/323188/One_chance_to_get_it_right.pdf
- NHS England. Ambitions for palliative and end of life care: a national framework for local action 2021-2026 [Internet]. 2021 May [cited 2026 Sept 1]. Available from: https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/ambitions-for-palliative-and-end-of-life-care-2nd-edition.pdf
- The Gold Standards Framework. Welcome to Gold Standards Framework [Internet]. The gold standards framework. 2022 [cited 2026 Aug 27]. Available from: https://www.goldstandardsframework.org.uk/
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Quality standard 144: care of dying adults in the last days of life [Internet]. NICE; 2017 [cited 2026 Aug 27]. Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs144
- General Medical Council. Treatment and care towards the end of life: Good practice in decision making professional standards [Internet]. 2024 Dec [cited 2026 Sept 1] p. 1–53. Available from: https://www.gmc-uk.org/cdn/documents/treatment-and-care-towards-the-end-of-life---english-1015_pdf-48902105.pdf
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Care of dying adults in the last days of life [Internet]. NICE; 2015 [cited 2026 Aug 27]. Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng31
- Wilcock A, Howard P, Stark Toller C, Droney J, Charlesworth S, editors. Palliative Care Formulary [Internet]. 2025 [cited 2026 Jan 8]. Available from: medicinescomplete.com
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Overview | shared decision making | guidance | NICE [Internet]. www.nice.org.uk. 2021 [cited 2026 Sept 1]. Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng197
- NICE. Decision-making and mental capacity [Internet]. NICE. 2018 [cited 2026 Sept 2]. Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng108
- Holm S, Edgar A. Best Interest: A Philosophical Critique. Health Care Analysis. 2008 July 19;16(3):197–207.
- Covino M, Sandroni C, Della Polla D, De Matteis G, Piccioni A, De Vita A, et al. Predicting ICU admission and death in the emergency department: A comparison of six early warning scores. Resuscitation [Internet]. 2023 Sept 1 [cited 2026 Aug 31];190:109876. Available from: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2023.109876
- Office for Health Improvement & Disparities. Palliative and end of life care profiles January 2025 update: Statistical commentary [Internet]. GOV.UK. 2025 [cited 2026 Sept 2]. Available from: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/palliative-and-end-of-life-care-profiles-january-2025-update/palliative-and-end-of-life-care-profiles-january-2025-update-statistical-commentary
- Becker KJ, Baxter AB, Cohen WA, Bybee HM, Tirschwell DL, Newell DW, et al. Withdrawal of support in intracerebral hemorrhage may lead to self-fulfilling prophecies. Neurology. 2001 Mar 27;56(6):766–72.
- White N, Reid F, Vickerstaff V, Harries P, Tomlinson C, Stone P. Imminent death: Clinician certainty and accuracy of prognostic predictions. BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care [Internet]. 2022 [cited 2026 Aug 31];12:e785–91. Available from: 10.1136/bmjspcare-2018-001761
- O’Connor T, Liu WM, Samara J, Lewis J, Paterson C. ‘How long do you think?’ Unresponsive dying patients in a specialist palliative care service: A consecutive cohort study. Palliative medicine [Internet]. 2024 Apr 23 [cited 2026 Sept 2];38(5). Available from: https://doi.org/10.1177/02692163241238903
Jon Rogers is an advanced paramedic specialising in urgent care